www.comparent.com - Comparent
Comparent
List Your Company Login

24 Vacation Property Managers in Holmes Beach, FL 34217, USA

Discover the top short-term vacation rental property managers in Holmes Beach, FL 34217, USA. Use the list below to find and compare the top property managers for your Airbnb property.

Market Overview

Market Leaders

Holmes Beach

Orlando

Owner Ratings

4

& Above

3

& Above

2

& Above

Airbnb logo

4

& Above

3

& Above

2

& Above

VRBO logo

4

& Above

3

& Above

2

& Above

Google logo

4

& Above

3

& Above

2

& Above

Expert Avatar

Need help choosing? Schedule a free 15-minute call with a Comparent expert to find the best vacation rental managers for you.

Talk to an Expert

The Cottages On The Key, Inc.

Headquarters Siesta Key, Florida

Airbnb Rating 4.8 (194)
VRBO Rating 4.8 (1466)
Google Rating 4.9 (322)
Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Airbnb Rating 4.8 (194)
VRBO Rating 4.8 (1466)
Google Rating 4.9 (322)
Welcome to The Cottages on the Key, an exclusive vacation rental management company with a boutique collection of luxury vacation homes located in Siesta Key, Lido Key, Anna Maria Island and the mainland of Sarasota, Florida. We offer... View full profile

Checkmate Rentals

Headquarters Pennsylvania

Airbnb Rating 4.9 (362)
Google Rating 4.9 (73)
Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Airbnb Rating 4.9 (362)
Google Rating 4.9 (73)
Checkmate Rentals changes the way you get to enjoy your vacation homes. With our professional, local caretaking teams in every market we manage, central support staff, and 24/7 customer service, we’ll be there every step of the way.W... View full profile
User Photo

Founded In 2024

PMI Manatee

Headquarters Bradenton, Florida

Employees 2

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Welcome to PMI Manatee, where we transform your property into a thriving investment. We are proud to lead a full-service short-term property management company dedicated to maximizing your property's potential.We understand that... View full profile
User Photo

Founded In 2022

Namastaze

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

NamaStaze! We are a boutique vacation rental management company on Anna Maria Island If you own a vacation property on AMI or Holmes Beach and are looking for an incredible team (who live and work on Anna Maria) and will give your home... View full profile
User Photo

Founded In 2009

Anna Maria Island Beach Rentals Inc.

Headquarters Bradenton Beach, Florida

Owner Rating 5.0 (9)
Airbnb Rating 4.6 (743)
VRBO Rating 4.6 (335)
Google Rating 4.0 (53)

VERIFIED

User Badge

VERIFIED

Owner Rating 5.0 (9)
Airbnb Rating 4.6 (743)
VRBO Rating 4.6 (335)
Google Rating 4.0 (53)
User Badge
Hi, we’re Terry and Sandy, the caring (and hands-on) owners and managers of Anna Maria Beach Condo. We’ve been here for years, so we know Anna Maria Island, the island’s condos, and our island’s guests. We understand you - what... View full profile

Need help choosing?

Schedule a free 15-minute call with a Comparent expert to find the best vacation rental managers for you.

Talk To An Advisor
User Photo

Founded In 2010

Florida Vacation Homes

Headquarters Davenport, Florida

Employees 45

Airbnb Rating 4.1 (890)
VRBO Rating 4.0 (1287)
Google Rating 4.0 (415)

VERIFIED

VERIFIED

Airbnb Rating 4.1 (890)
VRBO Rating 4.0 (1287)
Google Rating 4.0 (415)
Florida Vacation Homes offers full service management for the close to 300 short term rental properties in Central Florida in our portfolio. We are a preferred partner of Reunion Resort where we manage close to 200 properties. We utili... View full profile
User Photo

Founded In 2010

Dans Florida Condos, LLC

Headquarters Bradenton Beach, Florida

Employees 1-2

Google Rating 5.0 (66)

VERIFIED

VERIFIED

Google Rating 5.0 (66)
Hi I am Dan, the owner and operator of Dan’s Florida Condos, LLC, located on Anna Maria Island, Florida. I have owned and operated vacation rental properties on Anna Maria Island since 2010. I chose to invest in this area due to it... View full profile
User Photo

Founded In 2017

SeaBreeze Vacation

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

Employees 19

Google Rating 4.6 (120)

VERIFIED

VERIFIED

Google Rating 4.6 (120)
What started out as a vacation for our family expanded to thousands of vacations for many families. Just a year after visiting Anna Maria Island for the first time, we bought our first vacation rental here in 2002. She kept reeling us... View full profile
User Photo

Founded In 2017

Portfolio Vacations

Headquarters Bradenton , Florida

Employees 5

VERIFIED

VERIFIED

Portfolio Vacations is a boutique property management company on Anna Maria Island, Florida. We’re locally owned and operated and small by design. Giving our guests a 5 star experience is what we strive for every day. When you as... View full profile

Need help choosing?

Schedule a free 15-minute call with a Comparent expert to find the best vacation rental managers for you.

Talk To An Advisor

Florida Dreams Realty

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

VRBO Rating 4.6 (1768)
Google Rating 4.3 (96)
VRBO Rating 4.6 (1768)
Google Rating 4.3 (96)

A Paradise Realty

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

Airbnb Rating 4.5 (194)
VRBO Rating 4.5 (1165)
Google Rating 3.1 (9)
Airbnb Rating 4.5 (194)
VRBO Rating 4.5 (1165)
Google Rating 3.1 (9)

Anna Maria Vacations

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

VRBO Rating 4.5 (361)
Google Rating 4.1 (547)
VRBO Rating 4.5 (361)
Google Rating 4.1 (547)

Need help choosing?

Schedule a free 15-minute call with a Comparent expert to find the best vacation rental managers for you.

Talk To An Advisor

Salty Mermaid Real Estate & Vacation Rentals

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

Airbnb Rating 4.9 (386)
VRBO Rating 4.7 (194)
Google Rating 4.8 (60)
Airbnb Rating 4.9 (386)
VRBO Rating 4.7 (194)
Google Rating 4.8 (60)

Mike Norman Realty

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

Airbnb Rating 4.5 (139)
VRBO Rating 4.4 (240)
Google Rating 4.2 (82)
Airbnb Rating 4.5 (139)
VRBO Rating 4.4 (240)
Google Rating 4.2 (82)

Skipper & Associates Inc

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

VRBO Rating 4.7 (194)
Google Rating 5.0 (4)
VRBO Rating 4.7 (194)
Google Rating 5.0 (4)

Mainsail Lodging & Development

Headquarters Holmes Beach, Florida

VRBO Rating 4.9 (53)
Google Rating 4.6 (94)
VRBO Rating 4.9 (53)
Google Rating 4.6 (94)

About the Holmes Beach Short-Term Rental Market

Holmes Beach, located on the picturesque Anna Maria Island in Florida, has long been a popular destination for vacationers seeking a slice of coastal paradise. With its pristine beaches, laid-back atmosphere, and array of family-friendly activities, it's no surprise that the short-term rental market in Holmes Beach has experienced significant growth in recent years.

The demand for vacation rentals in Holmes Beach is driven by a variety of factors, including the island's year-round temperate climate, its proximity to major metropolitan areas like Tampa and Sarasota, and the increasing preference among travelers for more authentic, locally-immersive accommodations. As a result, the vacation rental market in Holmes Beach has become highly competitive, with property owners and management companies vying for a share of this lucrative industry.

Performance Benchmarks for Holmes Beach Vacation Rental Managers

According to data from vacation rental platforms like Airbnb and VRBO, the average nightly rate for vacation rentals in Holmes Beach is $350, with occupancy rates typically ranging from 60% to 80% depending on the season. The peak season, which runs from March to August, tends to see the highest demand and occupancy rates, while the shoulder seasons of September to November and January to February also experience strong bookings.

In terms of revenue performance, vacation rental properties in Holmes Beach have seen impressive returns. A recent market analysis by EasyStay USA found that a 6-bedroom oceanview property in Holmes Beach generated $185,560 in rental revenue in 2017, while a 3-bedroom property in the Emerald Bay community earned $82,390 and a 4-bedroom "Mermaid's Crossing" property brought in $124,382. These figures highlight the significant earning potential for well-managed vacation rental properties in the Holmes Beach market.

For a more detailed overview of the Holmes Beach vacation rental market, including additional performance data and insights, be sure to check out the Holmes Beach Market Overview.

How Competitive is the Holmes Beach Property Management Market?

The vacation rental market in Holmes Beach is highly competitive, with a diverse array of property management companies, both large and small, vying for a share of the market. This competitive landscape is driven by the strong demand for vacation rentals in the area, as well as the potential for lucrative returns for property owners.

According to a review of the top-ranking vacation rental management companies in Holmes Beach, the market is characterized by a mix of established local operators and larger, more nationally-recognized brands. These companies employ a range of strategies to attract and retain both property owners and guests, including leveraging technology, offering personalized service, and emphasizing their local expertise and connections.

The high level of competition in the Holmes Beach property management market means that vacation rental owners have a wide range of options when it comes to selecting a management partner. However, it also underscores the importance of working with a reputable and experienced company that can effectively market the property, optimize revenue, and provide exceptional guest experiences.

Key Players in the Holmes Beach Rental Market

Some of the leading vacation rental management companies in the Holmes Beach market include:

  • Beach Retreats Vacation Rentals - A boutique rental agency that specializes in high-end, luxury vacation rentals on Anna Maria Island, including properties in Holmes Beach. They pride themselves on personalized service and a hands-on approach to property management.
  • Island Vacation Properties, LLC - A full-service real estate company with a dedicated rental department that has been serving the Holmes Beach market for many years. They offer a range of vacation rental options and emphasize their local expertise and responsive management approach.
  • Island Real Estate Vacations LLC - A leading vacation rental management company in Holmes Beach that focuses on building strong partnerships with property owners. They leverage technology and data-driven strategies to optimize rental performance.
  • Beach Boutique Rentals - A local, on-the-ground team of property management and vacation rental specialists that serves the Holmes Beach and greater Anna Maria Island market. They pride themselves on their personalized service and growing portfolio of high-quality rental properties.
  • Coquina Concierge Property Management - A boutique property management company that specializes in serving the Holmes Beach, Longboat Key, Bird Key, and surrounding areas. They offer a range of services, including vacation rental management, to meet the needs of their clients.

These are just a few of the key players in the Holmes Beach vacation rental management market, each offering a unique value proposition and approach to serving property owners and guests. As the demand for vacation rentals in the area continues to grow, the competition among these companies is likely to intensify, driving innovation and raising the bar for service excellence.